← All articles

Consultant

Amazon vs CNPD: fine annulled, GDPR legitimate interest weakened

Luxembourg’s Administrative Court annulled Amazon’s record fine but upheld GDPR violations and requires proof of “fault” to impose penalties. Legitimate interest for behavioral ads emerges weakened.

On 12 March 2026, Luxembourg’s Administrative Court annulled the CNPD’s record €746m fine against Amazon — while upholding GDPR violations and ordering a reassessment based on “fault” as clarified by the CJEU. Key takeaway: “legitimate interest” alone does not justify large‑scale behavioral advertising without robust, transparent, and well‑documented safeguards. Justice source; CNPD position. (justice.public.lu)

The case

  • Organisation: Amazon Europe Core S.à r.l. (Luxembourg). Authority: CNPD.
  • Initial decision: 15 July 2021, €746m fine and corrective orders with penalties, for shortcomings in targeted advertising and transparency.
  • Litigation: the Administrative Tribunal (18 Mar 2025) had upheld the decision; the Administrative Court (12 Mar 2026, No. 52757C) annulled it and remitted the case for fresh analysis.
  • Ground for annulment: per the CJEU (5 Dec 2023, C‑807/21 Deutsche Wohnen; C‑683/21 Nacionalinis), an administrative fine under Art. 83 GDPR requires proof of a culpable infringement (intentional or negligent).
  • Points upheld: compliance achieved meanwhile, rendering injunctions moot; core findings of infringement maintained (including insufficient legal basis for targeted ads and transparency failures).

See Justice Luxembourg and CNPD; on “fault”: CJEU 5/12/2023. (justice.public.lu)

Legal reasoning

1) Legal basis (Article 6 GDPR) and behavioral advertising

The 2021 decision — whose core findings were not overturned — found Amazon’s legal basis for targeted advertising insufficient. The CNPD considered that “legitimate interest” (Art. 6(1)(f)) could not cover the operations without robust safeguards and enhanced transparency. The Court set aside the fine for procedural reasons under Article 83 but did not refute the substantive findings, remitting the case for reassessment. Justice; CNPD. (justice.public.lu)

The interpretative framework is set by EDPB Guidelines 1/2024 on Article 6(1)(f): a three‑part test (legitimate purpose, necessity, and balancing), heightened scrutiny for intrusive processing, and reinforced transparency. For large‑scale behavioral ads, limited reasonable expectations and information asymmetry weigh against the controller. EDPB announcement; Guidelines 1/2024. (edpb.europa.eu)

2) GDPR fines (Article 83) and the “fault” requirement

The Court relies on the CJEU (Grand Chamber, 5 Dec 2023): fines are lawful only where the infringement is culpable (intentional or negligent). Supervisory authorities must establish fault by the controller/processor, considering Article 83(2) GDPR criteria. Cases C‑807/21 and C‑683/21 harmonize burden and object of proof across Member States. CJEU release. (curia.europa.eu)

3) CNPD’s public stance

The CNPD “notes” the judgment, highlights achieved compliance, and states its “key findings” were upheld, announcing it will continue reassessment in line with the CJEU’s procedural standard. CNPD. (cnpd.public.lu)

What this changes in practice

  • Behavioral ads and marketing analytics: in Luxembourg, invoking “legitimate interest” for large‑scale profiling/retargeting is high risk unless the balancing test is evidenced with technical safeguards (minimization, granularity, user controls) and clear information (Arts. 13‑14). Local case law shows the authority will probe the legal basis and transparency on the merits, even though fines require proof of fault. Justice; EDPB.
  • Evidence governance: to meet Article 83, document due diligence: necessity analyses, balancing tests, configuration logs, design decisions (privacy by design, Art. 25), and periodic checks. In investigations, this helps show lack of negligence. CJEU reference: fault is required for monetary sanctions. CJEU 5/12/2023.
  • Legal basis strategy: for opt‑in channels (B2C email/SMS), consent remains a safer route. For targeted ads and intra‑group marketing, legitimate interest narrows and demands technical limits (no sensitive/inferred data, short retention, audience controls) and easy opt‑outs. EDPB 1/2024.

To structure your compliance and engagement with the CNPD, a dedicated DPO mandate can secure governance and documentation. From a legal standpoint, align practices with the GDPR in Luxembourg and the Article 6(1)(f) framework.

Common pitfalls

  1. Confusing “information” with effective transparency: lengthy but opaque notices do not create reasonable expectations (Arts. 12‑14). For behavioral ads, explain profiling logic, data categories, recipients, and user choices. Justice.
  2. Relying on legitimate interest without a written test and safeguards: missing the three‑step test, ignoring information asymmetry and expectations, and lacking privacy‑by‑default settings (Art. 25) are red flags. EDPB 1/2024.
  3. Forgetting proof of absence of negligence for fines: even where an infringement is found, fines require fault. Without internal records (governance, controls, audits, decisions), a key defense is lost. CJEU, 5/12/2023.
  4. Mixing cookie consent with processing legal basis: ePrivacy consent for terminal access/storage is not a substitute for the GDPR legal basis for subsequent processing. Combine both as appropriate. Art. 6 and 5(1)(a) GDPR; EDPB guidance. EDPB.
  5. Underestimating group effects: intra‑group sharing for marketing is not automatically covered by legitimate interest; map purposes per entity and any transfers (Arts. 26, 28, 30, 44 ff.). EDPB 1/2024.

Official sources

In brief: the “Amazon” ruling does not green‑light behavioral advertising based solely on legitimate interest; it raises the evidentiary bar (documented balancing, effective transparency, privacy by design) and demands proof‑ready governance to avoid a finding of negligence justifying a fine. The EDPB provides the method; the Administrative Court and CJEU set the evidentiary standard.

Need operational support and a point of contact with the CNPD? Reach out via our contact page.

Luxgap regulatory expertise article. For personalised guidance on this topic, contact us or configure your online quote.

How Luxgap can help

External DPO

An outsourced DPO, registered with the CNPD, takes charge of your GDPR compliance: records of processing, DPIAs, data subject rights, breaches and processor contracts.

How our external DPO works
LUXGAP NEWSLETTER

Get our analyses the moment they drop.

GDPR, NIS 2, AI expertise articles, plus invitations to free webinars + trainings at Luxgap. 1 to 2 emails per week max, one-click unsubscribe.

Your data is never shared. GDPR-compliant (we're DPOs after all).

A question on this topic?

Our team usually replies within one business day. Configure your quote or write to us.

Build my quote →